Badger 1 Vs Badger 5 Garbage Disposal; What’s the Difference? 

Badger 1 and Badger 5 garbage disposals have the same design, same build, and same color combination, making them difficult to distinguish from one another. In addition, both use a one-stage grinding mechanism, have 26 oz grinding chamber capacity, Dura-Drive motors that run at 1725 RPM, stainless steel swivel lugs, and galvanized steel grinding elements. Not to mention that they’re both produced by the same manufacturer; Insinkerator.  In fact, were it not for the stickers pasted on them, you would think they are one and the same thing. So, how do you differentiate Badger 1 Vs Badger 5? More importantly, which is a better choice for you; Badger 1 or Badger 5? 

Well, let’s start with some notable features that will help you differentiate these garbage disposals! 

Major differences between Badger 1 vs Badger 5 

• Appearance and size 

Unlike Insinkerator Evolution Series, both Badger 1 and 5 garbage disposals are quite modest in appearance. They lack a premium feel and look like standard garbage disposals, giving you only what you need in an affordable range. Moreover, they don’t have any additional features as they’re only designed to fulfill their primary purpose with their continuous feed type, industrial build, and galvanized steel grinding components. 

However, despite this resemblance in appearance, Badger 1 and 5 have different weights. Specifically, the body of the Badger 1 weighs 12.7 lbs, while the Badger 5 model weighs 13.6 lbs since it’s slightly larger and has a high-powered motor. 

• Power and performance 

Talking of motors, Badger 1 garbage disposal is equipped with a ⅓ HP Dura-Drive Induction motor, while Badger 5 comes with ½ HP Dura-Drive Induction motor. This makes the motor of the Badger 5 almost 50% more powerful than that of the Badger 1. This makes Badger 1 ideal for occasional use in small households of up to 2 persons. On the other hand, Badger 5 can handle food waste of more than 3 people since it’s more powerful. 

• Noise Level 

As mentioned earlier, both Badger 1 and 5 are standard budget-friendly garbage disposals. In addition, they don’t have any noise-insulation materials as is the case with the Insinkerator Evolution Series. As a result, both units are quite loud during operation. So, if you’re looking for the quietest garbage disposal, I’d recommend you explore other options instead of Badger 1 or 5 models. 

• Warranty 

Another important factor that will help you determine whether Badger 1 or 5 will suit your kitchen requirements is the warranty. Generally, the longer the warranty period, the more chances of testing the appliances while having adequate time to replace them if anything happens. 

That said, Insinkerator Badger 1 disposal only comes with a 1-year warranty. For that, you cannot enjoy the appliance in the long run as you’ll not get access to parts or unit replacement once that period elapses. 

In comparison, the Badger 5 disposal is backed by a 2-year warranty. This will keep your mind relaxed when using the device even after exceeding the first year since you can easily make claims for parts/ unit replacement in case of an emergency. 

• Installation 

Similar to other Insinkerator garbage disposals, both Badger 1 and 5 come with a stainless steel quick lock sink mount assembly. This makes it easy to install or uninstall the units when you want to replace them. 

Unfortunately, despite having an easy installation process, Badger 1 and 5 don’t include everything you need in the box. For instance, you have to buy the dishwasher connection kit and power cord separately if you need them. 

Other than that, you’ll get everything you need to install your Badger 1 or 5 garbage disposal under the kitchen sink. Specifically, both units come with a Jam-Buster wrench, tailpipe gasket, tailpipe, stopper, and Quick Lock Sink mount. 

Notable Similarities between Badger 1 vs Bader 5 Garbage Disposals 

As already mentioned, both Badger 1 and Badger 5 are made by Insinkerator, a well-known garbage disposal manufacturer that produces high-quality and long-lasting units. Therefore, you can rest assured that both Badger 1 and 5 will last and withstand regular use in any kitchen. 

Secondly, both garbage disposal models use a continuous feed system, meaning you can add food waste to the units while they’re still running. This makes it easy to get rid of food scraps fast and efficiently since you don’t have to stop and start the unit multiple times like in batch-feed garbage disposals. 

As for the construction, both units have high-durable and rust-resistant galvanized steel. For that, both models can withstand tough food scraps without deteriorating or corroding over time. 

Another key similarity between Badger 1 and 5 is their dimensions as they both measure 11.5 x 6.3 x 6.3”. This allows them to fit comfortably and install under any kitchen sink without having to worry about space constraints. 

Speaking about the installation, Badger 1 and 5 models use a 3-bolt mounting assembly, making the installation process quick and easy. On top of that, they have an optional pre-installed power cord, meaning you can either choose to use it or not based on your specific installation needs. 

Finally, the grinding chamber of both Badger 1 and Badger 5 has a capacity of 26 oz. Therefore, they can handle a decent amount of food scraps at once, making them ideal for small to medium-sized households. 

Which is better; Badger 1 or Badger 5? 

Overall, the Insinkerator Badger 1 and 5 garbage disposals have several key similarities. This makes both units an excellent option for anyone looking for reliable and budget-friendly garbage disposal. Even better, you can replace one model with another since their size and specs are almost the same. 

However, there are some key differences between Badger 1 and 5 as well. These differences will help you determine the ideal garbage disposal to meet your kitchen needs when choosing between Badger 1 and 5 models. 

Generally speaking, Badger 5 is better than Badger 1 as it has a longer warranty, better specs, and a stronger motor. The only issue with Badger 5 is that it’s more costly than its Badger 1 counterpart, but only with a few dollars.